Hello, this is attorney Jonghan Park of Cheongchul Law Firm.
This time, we look at when a landowner who has become a cash-out party (현금청산대상자) loses union membership, dividing the question into the case where no unit application is filed and the case where no sale contract is signed.
[Question]
Does a cash-out party lose union membership? If so, when does the loss occur, and is membership restored if the project implementation plan later lapses?
[Answer]
A. A cash-out party loses union membership
The Urban and Residential Environment Improvement Act (도시 및 주거환경정비법, hereinafter the "Urban Improvement Act") merely requires the project implementer to negotiate compensation with cash-out parties such as those who did not apply for a unit (Urban Improvement Act Article 73(1) (도시정비법 제73조 제1항)). It has no express provision on their membership status, so the question is one of interpretation.
The Supreme Court, in its decision of August 19, 2010 (Case No. 2009Da81203), held that "a member who has become a cash-out party by meeting the requirements of Article 47 of the Urban Improvement Act and the union's articles of association, such as by not applying for a unit or withdrawing the application, is a member who has become a cash-out party and is reasonably deemed to lose his or her status as a member." The Supreme Court decision of July 23, 2015 (Case No. 2014Du39593) likewise stated that "a member who has become a cash-out party by meeting the requirements of Article 47 of the former Urban Improvement Act and the union's articles of association, such as by not applying for a unit or withdrawing the application, loses membership status," and concluded that the union cannot impose or collect improvement project cost contributions from cash-out parties (now Article 73 of the Urban Improvement Act). However, that decision added that the union may settle such costs in the settlement process or seek their return separately only "where it has been determined in advance, by the union's articles of association, a resolution of the general meeting of members, or an agreement between the union and the member, that the cash-out party must bear a certain portion of the union's improvement project costs incurred before he or she lost membership status."
B. Where no unit application is filed : the day after the application period ends
The 2009Da81203 decision above held that "the point at which membership is lost should be determined in the same way as the time at which the cash settlement relationship arises and the union's duty to pay the settlement amount accrues in a reconstruction project, and as the reference date for valuing the land and other rights subject to cash settlement, so that a member who did not apply for a unit or withdrew the application loses membership on the day after the application period ends."
Once lost, membership does not revive even if the project implementation plan later lapses. The Supreme Court decision of February 10, 2021 (Case No. 2020Du48031) held that "if a member of a housing redevelopment project union does not apply for a unit in the application procedure, he or she becomes a cash-out party and loses membership on the day after the application period ends," and that "even if the project implementation plan underlying that application procedure subsequently lapses due to expiry of the project period, abolition, or the like, such lapse takes effect only prospectively, so the legal effect of withdrawal from the union that had already occurred is not retroactively extinguished, nor can the membership already lost be regarded as automatically restored."
C. Where no sale contract is signed : the day after the contract-signing period ends
Where the articles of association or the management and disposal plan designate as cash-out parties those members who fail to sign a sale contract within the contract-signing period, the Supreme Court decision of July 28, 2011 (Case No. 2008Da91364) held that a member "may, even after the management and disposal plan has been approved, by failing to sign a sale contract within the contract-signing period set in the articles of association as described above, become a cash-out party absent special circumstances."
As to the timing, the Supreme Court decision of December 22, 2011 (Case No. 2011Du17936) held that "the project implementer's duty to pay the settlement amount to a person who initially applied for a unit but additionally became a cash-out party by failing to sign a sale contract must be regarded as arising on ‘the day after the contract-signing period ends’." The Supreme Court decision of August 13, 2020 (Case No. 2017Da236022) found no "error of law or insufficient deliberation regarding the point at which membership is lost that affected the judgment" in the lower court's finding that the member "lost membership status on September 18, 2012, the day after the end of the initial contract-signing period set by the plaintiff after approval of the management plan."
This presupposes, however, that the union demanded that the member sign a sale contract and the member refused. Accordingly, the Supreme Court decision of December 15, 2016 (Case No. 2015Du51309) upheld a lower court ruling that a member who could not sign a sale contract because he or she never received notice to do so does not qualify as a cash-out party on the ground of failure to sign a sale contract.
-----
Cheongchul Law Firm is composed solely of attorneys with backgrounds at Korea's five largest law firms, Kim & Chang, Lee & Ko, Bae, Kim & Lee, Shin & Kim and Yulchon, and at the prosecutors' office. Rather than a single attorney, a team of specialists in the fields relevant to each matter works together to respond. Going beyond resolving isolated issues, Cheongchul provides comprehensive solutions across the client's business, focusing its legal consulting on ultimately achieving what the client wants. If you need help reaching your goals, please do not hesitate to contact Cheongchul.
Related work cases that are good to see together
서울 강남구 테헤란로 403 리치타워 7층
Tel. 02-6959-9936
Fax. 02-6959-9967
cheongchul@cheongchul.com
개인정보처리방침
면책공고
© 2025. Cheongchul. All rights reserved
![[건설] 현금청산대상자의 조합원 지위 상실 시점 - 분양신청기간 종료일 다음날, 분양계약체결기간 종료일 다음날, 사업시행계획 실효 시 조합원 지위 회복 여부와 정비사업비 분담](https://framerusercontent.com/images/uF1DEoRe5isO4bLZABnIU4KcQg.png?width=1080&height=1350)


