Hello, this is Cheongchul Law Firm.
When a customer files a complaint or lawsuit over mis-selling and the insurer pays a settlement, the company sometimes notifies the agent in charge to "repay the full amount." From the agent's side, it can be hard to know whether you must simply absorb whatever amount the company decided.
In short, you are not automatically liable for the full amount. The insurer's compensation to the customer and its recourse claim against the agent are judged separately, and the scope of recourse can vary depending on how much the agent's fault contributed to the loss, whether the company's supervision was adequate, and whether the settlement amount was reasonable. This post explains that framework and the records to prepare.
[Contents]
The Insurer's Payout and Recourse Against the Agent Are Separate
Recourse Covers Only the Agent's Share of Fault
Weak Supervision and Sales Monitoring by the Insurer
Whether the Settlement Amount Was Reasonable Can Be Disputed
Received a Demand for Full Repayment? Records to Check
The Insurer's Payout and Recourse Against the Agent Are Separate
The insurer's liability and right of recourse once set out in Article 102 of the former Insurance Business Act are now found in Article 45 of the Financial Consumer Protection Act (금융소비자 보호에 관한 법률). Paragraph 1 provides that a direct seller of financial products, such as an insurer, is liable for losses that agents who sell its products on its behalf cause to financial consumers in the course of their work. Paragraph 2 provides that this liability does not prevent the insurer from exercising a right of recourse against the agent.
In other words, paragraph 1 concerns the insurer and the consumer, while paragraph 2 concerns the insurer and the agent afterwards. The fact that the insurer compensated the consumer does not by itself mean the agent must pay back the same amount. How much was paid to the consumer and how much of it the agent should bear are separate questions.
Recourse Covers Only the Agent's Share of Fault
Recourse targets the part of the loss to which the agent's wrongdoing contributed. The Supreme Court of Korea holds that when an employer bears liability for an employee's tort committed in the course of work and then seeks recourse against the employee, it may do so only to the extent deemed reasonable under the principle of good faith, considering the nature and scale of the business, the employee's duties and working conditions, the cause and nature of the wrongful act, and the extent of the employer's care in preventing such acts or spreading the loss, from the standpoint of fair allocation of the loss (Supreme Court Decision 86Da-ka1045, September 8, 1987; Supreme Court Decision 2009Da59350, November 26, 2009).
Most insurance agents work under commission (appointment) contracts rather than employment contracts, but the structure is similar: the insurer first bears liability for the agent's sales activity and then claims against the agent. In fact, in lower court cases where insurers sought recourse from agents, courts have weighed the agent's share of fault and the company's own duty to verify and supervise, and limited recourse to part of the loss. We introduced specific cases in Key Rulings Overturning Claim Denials.
Weak Supervision and Sales Monitoring by the Insurer
The proviso to Article 45(1) of the Financial Consumer Protection Act provides that the insurer is not liable if it exercised due care in appointing and supervising the agent and made efforts to prevent the loss. Seen the other way, the insurer's payment to the consumer may mean the company could not show that it met this supervisory duty, or chose not to contest the point.
The Supreme Court's framework also lists "the extent of the employer's care in preventing such acts or spreading the loss" as a factor in setting the scope of recourse. If the company did not provide proper product training, ran its sales-completion monitoring (so-called "happy calls") as a mere formality, or ignored warning signs, the agent's share may be reduced accordingly.
There is a limit, however. The Supreme Court holds that a person who intentionally committed a wrongful act by exploiting the employer's lax supervision cannot, under the principle of good faith, rely on that very laxity to seek a reduction (the 2009Da59350 decision above). If an agent signed on the customer's behalf or knowingly gave false explanations, it will be difficult to reduce the burden by pointing to the company's weak supervision.
Whether the Settlement Amount Was Reasonable Can Be Disputed
Article 45(2), the basis for recourse, presupposes liability under the main text of paragraph 1, that is, the insurer's legal liability to compensate the consumer. In practice, however, many cases never reach court, and the company sets an amount and settles at the complaint stage.
The mere fact that the company paid does not settle the entire amount as a loss for which the agent is responsible. For example, if the consumer was also at fault for not checking the policy terms, so that damages would have been reduced in litigation, but the company settled without reflecting this, or if it paid more than its legal liability to resolve the complaint or protect its reputation, there is room to argue that the excess should not be treated as the agent's share.
So when you receive a recourse claim, first check how the company reached the settlement with the customer and on what basis it calculated the amount. If the company cannot show the basis for its calculation, that itself becomes a point of dispute.
Received a Demand for Full Repayment? Records to Check
A notice from the company to "repay everything" does not have to be accepted as is. The fault ratio and the reasonableness of the settlement can be disputed, and it is advisable to secure the following records.
Explanation materials at the time of sale: application forms, product descriptions, explanation confirmations, call recordings, and texts or emails with the customer showing that you explained properly and completed the paperwork
Sales-completion monitoring records: happy-call results and the customer's answers during the call
Company training and supervision records: product training completion, sales inspection results, and manager review procedures
Settlement history and calculation basis: the complaint, the settlement agreement, and the basis on which the company set the amount
Appointment contract and company rules: provisions on damages, recourse and clawbacks
Even if the appointment contract or company rules say you will bear the full amount "regardless of the reason," it cannot be assumed that such a clause will be enforced as written. A similar issue has been addressed in clawback disputes, and we summarized the relevant Supreme Court decision in Insurance Agent Clawbacks: Check Before You Repay. Signing a confirmation or payment undertaking presented by the company right away may make it harder to dispute later, so check the records first before responding.
To sum up: ① the insurer's compensation and recourse against the agent are separate; ② recourse may be limited to a reasonable extent under the principle of good faith, within the range to which the agent's fault contributed; and ③ the insurer's weak supervision and ④ the reasonableness of the settlement can also reduce the agent's share. However, for intentional misconduct, a reduction based on lax supervision is unlikely to be accepted.
Cheongchul Law Firm provides legal advice and litigation services in disputes involving insurance agents' appointment contracts, termination, clawbacks and recourse claims. If you have received a large recourse claim, please contact us through consultation booking.
This post is written for the purpose of providing legal information and does not constitute legal advice on any specific matter. Since conclusions may differ depending on the facts of each case, please be sure to consult a professional.
Related work cases that are good to see together
서울 강남구 테헤란로 403 리치타워 7층
Tel. 02-6959-9936
Fax. 02-6959-9967
cheongchul@cheongchul.com
개인정보처리방침
면책공고
© 2025. Cheongchul. All rights reserved



