Hello, this is Cheongchul Law Firm.
A subcontractor that has not been paid may provisionally attach the construction payment the main contractor is due to receive from the project owner, only for the main contractor and the owner to later agree to cancel the contract and claim that 'the money to be attached no longer exists.' Until now, such arguments were generally accepted. However, the Supreme Court changed this standard in an en banc decision on September 29, 2026.
This article explains what the changed precedent says and why, the three cases in which mutual rescission is exceptionally recognized, and what owners and creditors should each do.
[Contents]
A Precedent Changed After 25 Years – What Is Different
Why It Changed – The Prohibition-on-Disposal Effect of Provisional Attachment
Three Cases Where Mutual Rescission Still Works
If You Are the Owner (Third-Party Debtor) – How You End the Contract Matters
If You Are Owed Construction Payments – Find the Claim and Attach It Fast
A Precedent Changed After 25 Years – What Is Different
The previous precedent held that, except in special cases such as where the debtor and the third-party debtor mutually rescinded the contract without any reasonable ground solely to extinguish the claim, the third-party debtor could, even after an attachment or provisional attachment, assert against the attaching creditor that the claim had been extinguished by mutual rescission of the contract (Supreme Court Decision 98Da17930, June 1, 2001, and others). The reasoning was that a provisional attachment seizes the money to be received, not the contract itself, so whether to end the contract is up to the parties.
The Supreme Court changed this rule. If, after an attachment or provisional attachment of a claim takes effect, the debtor and the third-party debtor mutually rescind or mutually terminate the contract from which the claim arises, the third-party debtor in principle cannot assert against the attaching or provisionally attaching creditor that the claim has been extinguished as a result (Supreme Court en banc Decision 2023Da275578, September 29, 2026). Decision 98Da17930 and other decisions to the contrary were all overruled.
The case began with a contract to transfer a biogas power generation business for 850 million won. A creditor of the transferor provisionally attached 350 million won of the transfer price claim, converted it to a final attachment and obtained a collection order, but the transferee argued that the transfer contract had been mutually rescinded in the meantime and the price claim had therefore disappeared. The lower court dismissed the creditor's claim under the previous rule, but the Supreme Court reversed and remanded the case.
Why It Changed – The Prohibition-on-Disposal Effect of Provisional Attachment
When a claim is attached, the court prohibits the third-party debtor from paying the debtor and prohibits the debtor from disposing of or receiving the claim (Article 227(1) of the Civil Execution Act (민사집행법)). A provisional attachment order only directs the third-party debtor not to pay the debtor (Article 296(3) of the same Act), but the Supreme Court has recognized that provisional attachment also has a prohibition-on-disposal effect. This decision applied that effect, under which a debtor's disposal that extinguishes or reduces the claim after attachment cannot be asserted against the attaching creditor, to mutual rescission as well.
The Supreme Court's reasons were as follows. Statutory or contractual rescission exercises a right of rescission that already existed in the law or the contract before the attachment. Mutual rescission, by contrast, is a new contract that the debtor and the third-party debtor, both bound by the attachment order, conclude after the attachment, and in the end it is no different from an act extinguishing the attached claim. The provisionally attaching creditor is not a party to that agreement and can hardly even know about it. If mutual rescission could nevertheless neutralize a provisional attachment, the time and money the creditor invested would be wasted and the effectiveness of the compulsory execution system would decline.
The Supreme Court held that this risk should in principle be borne by the debtor, who was attached for failing to perform its obligation, and by the third-party debtor, who agreed to the rescission despite having been served with the attachment order. Mutual rescission is not prohibited, however. It remains valid between the debtor and the third-party debtor; its effect simply cannot be asserted against the attaching creditor.
Three Cases Where Mutual Rescission Still Works
The Supreme Court held that mutual rescission can be asserted against the attaching or provisionally attaching creditor in the following cases.
Where grounds for rescission already existed: cases where the requirements of a separate ground for ending the contract, such as statutory or contractual rescission, were met but the rescission merely took the form of mutual rescission. For example, if the main contractor failed to perform the work so that the contractual requirements for rescission were already satisfied, but the matter was wrapped up under the name of 'mutual rescission,' it is in substance a legitimate rescission.
Money that will arise in the future under a continuing contract: future claims arising period by period under a continuing contract, such as rent under a lease or wages under an employment contract. Rent already accrued and unpaid at the time of the provisional attachment is subject to the prohibition-on-disposal effect, but the parties cannot be prevented from mutually terminating the contract so that future rent no longer arises.
Where denying the effect would be grossly unjust: cases with special circumstances in light of the nature and content of the contract and claim, the weight of the claim within the contract, and how the mutual rescission came about. Examples given include where only a claim under one of several contracts made as a single package was attached, or where the attached claim is extremely minor in the overall contract or arises merely from an ancillary agreement.
Importantly, these exceptions must be proven by the party seeking to rely on the mutual rescission, usually the third-party debtor. The same rule applies where the mutual rescission occurred after a provisional attachment but before it was converted into a final attachment.
If You Are the Owner (Third-Party Debtor) – How You End the Contract Matters
A third-party debtor that has been served with a provisional attachment order, such as a project owner, should no longer assume that an agreement with the main contractor settles everything. If there are reasons to end the contract, it should rescind on the basis of the contract's rescission clause or statutory grounds, and keep records of how the grounds arose and what notices were given. This is because it is the third-party debtor that will later have to prove an exception.
As reasons why the new rule is not unfair to third-party debtors, the Supreme Court noted that a third-party debtor can still exercise statutory rescission rights and the like, can assert defenses that arose before the attachment, and can be released from its payment obligation by making a deposit under Article 248 of the Civil Execution Act. At the provisional attachment stage, the debtor can also deposit a release amount to have the execution cancelled. If the third-party debtor ends up having to perform because it cannot rely on the mutual rescission, it may, absent special circumstances, seek repayment of the amount performed from the debtor.
If You Are Owed Construction Payments – Find the Claim and Attach It Fast
For those who are owed construction payments, such as subcontractors, this decision greatly increases the effectiveness of provisional attachment. If you quickly find out from which owner the main contractor is due to receive how much, and attach that claim, then even if the main contractor and the owner later mutually rescind the contract, that effect in principle cannot be asserted against you.
If the third-party debtor refuses payment after the attachment on the ground of mutual rescission, you can require it to prove one of the three exceptions above and proceed to a final attachment and collection after obtaining an enforceable title. The priority between a subcontractor's direct payment claim and a provisional attachment by the main contractor's creditor is covered in Direct Pay vs. Provisional Seizure, and the limitation period and lien for construction payments in Unpaid Construction Payment? Check These First.
In short, after a provisional attachment, the parties' claim that 'we agreed to cancel the contract' in principle no longer works against the attaching creditor. Exceptions are recognized only where grounds for rescission already existed, where the claim is a future claim under a continuing contract, or where denying the effect would be grossly unjust, and the burden of proof lies with the party asserting the mutual rescission.
Cheongchul Law Firm directly handles construction disputes, including claims for construction and subcontract payments, provisional attachment and collection of claims, and responses on the owner's side. If you are facing a provisional attachment or a contract rescission, please contact us through consultation booking.
This post is written for the purpose of providing legal information and does not constitute legal advice on any specific matter. Since conclusions may differ depending on the facts of each case, please be sure to consult a professional.
Related work cases that are good to see together
서울 강남구 테헤란로 403 리치타워 7층
Tel. 02-6959-9936
Fax. 02-6959-9967
cheongchul@cheongchul.com
개인정보처리방침
면책공고
© 2025. Cheongchul. All rights reserved



