단톡방에서 욕하면 모욕죄? - 카카오톡 1:1 대화·단톡방 욕설의 모욕죄 성립 기준(공연성·피해자 특정·표현의 맥락)

Swearing in a Group Chat: Is It Criminal Insult?

Swearing in a Group Chat: Is It Criminal Insult?

Swearing in a Group Chat: Is It Criminal Insult?

Hello, this is Cheongchul Law Firm.

It is not uncommon for someone to send a single swear word on KakaoTalk and then face a criminal complaint for insult. Even with the same swear word, the outcome differs depending on whether it was sent in a one-on-one chat or in a group chat with many people, and on whether the other person swore first.

The video compared the risk in each situation intuitively by assigning scores. Since the actual decision is made according to the requirements of Article 311 of the Criminal Act (형법) and the standards set by the Supreme Court, this article applies each situation in the video to those standards one by one.

[Contents]

  1. Three Things Decide a Criminal Insult

  2. One-on-One Chats and Messages to a Friend – Publicity and Likelihood of Spread

  3. Group Chats, and Insults That Identify Someone Without a Name

  4. If the Other Person Swore First – Circumstances and Context

  5. Can It Be an Insult Without Swear Words – The Level of Expression

Three Things Decide a Criminal Insult

Article 311 of the Criminal Act provides that 'a person who publicly insults another shall be punished by imprisonment with or without labor for not more than one year or by a fine not exceeding two million won.' Three things must be examined under this provision.

  • Publicity: whether the expression was made in a state that an unspecified or large number of people could perceive

  • Identification of the victim: whether it can be known at whom the expression was directed

  • An insulting expression: whether the expression is contemptuous enough to lower the other person's social reputation

If specific facts were disclosed to damage the other person's reputation, the issue is defamation, not insult. The Information and Communications Network Act (정보통신망법) has a provision separately punishing defamation through information networks (Article 70), but no provision separately punishing insult, so swearing on KakaoTalk is also judged under Article 311 of the Criminal Act.

Insult is an offense that can be prosecuted only upon the victim's complaint (Article 312(1) of the Criminal Act), and the complaint must be filed within six months from the date the offender became known (Article 230(1) of the Criminal Procedure Act).

One-on-One Chats and Messages to a Friend – Publicity and Likelihood of Spread

The Supreme Court regards publicity as 'a state that an unspecified or large number of people can perceive,' and maintains the so-called likelihood-of-spread doctrine, under which publicity can be recognized even if the statement was made to a few people, as long as those people might spread it to an unspecified or large number of people (Supreme Court en banc Decision 2020Do5813, November 19, 2020). The same doctrine applies to publicity in the crime of insult.

However, the Supreme Court held that the fact that the statement was made only to a specific few can be a strong reason to deny publicity, so the prosecutor must strictly prove the likelihood of spread, and the speaker must also have recognized the likelihood of spread and accepted that risk (dolus eventualis). The fact that it was not actually spread can be considered as weighing against publicity (Supreme Court Decision 2022Do14571, January 4, 2024).

If the swearing was sent one-on-one to the other person only, the only person who sees the conversation is that person, so publicity is in principle hard to recognize. However, repeatedly sending messages that cause fear or anxiety may raise a violation of the Information and Communications Network Act separate from insult (Article 74(1)3, imprisonment of up to one year or a fine of up to 10 million won).

If a KakaoTalk message swearing about someone else was sent to a single friend, the issue is whether there was an objective likelihood that the friend would spread the content to others. In the above Decision 2022Do14571, where a district council member sent a negative KakaoTalk message about a member of a volunteer patrol group to the group's leader alone, the Supreme Court held that it was hard to conclude there was publicity, citing the two people's positions and relationship, the circumstances in which the message was sent, and the fact that the leader did not pass the message on, and reversed the guilty verdict. Conversely, if the recipient was in a relationship likely to pass the content on, or there were circumstances in which the conversation was likely to spread, the outcome could differ.

Group Chats, and Insults That Identify Someone Without a Name

If you swore at a specific employee in a company group chat, many people can see the message right away. The likelihood that it falls under a state that an unspecified or large number of people can perceive becomes much greater than in a one-on-one chat. The number of participants and nature of the group chat, and how the conversation unfolded, are also considered.

If you swore without using a name but in a way that made it clear who was meant, such as 'the youngest on our team', identification of the victim becomes the issue. While the Supreme Court held that the victim of insult must be identified, it also held that where the group is small or the surrounding circumstances at the time indicate that an individual member of the group is being referred to, that person is identified as the victim (Supreme Court Decision 2011Do15631, March 27, 2014). It does not end simply because no real name was used; the standard is whether the people in the group chat could tell who was being referred to.

If the Other Person Swore First – Circumstances and Context

It is not the case that your swearing is automatically excused just because the other person swore at you harshly first. However, the Supreme Court holds that whether an expression is an insult must be judged objectively in light of the parties' relationship, the circumstances leading to the expression, the manner of expression, and the situation at the time, taking into account the overall context and whether the expression was made spontaneously (Supreme Court Decision 2025Do3012, May 8, 2026). The other person's behavior is exactly part of these 'circumstances.'

In a case where a person turned around and swore once after someone holding a one-person protest loudly called out to him in casual speech, the Supreme Court held that a one-off, spontaneous or impulsive swear word roughly expressing dissatisfaction or anger in response to the other person's behavior only hurts that person's feelings of honor and is hard to regard as an insult lowering their social reputation (Supreme Court Decision 2023Do14750, May 29, 2026). The case introduced in the video, in which someone said 'what human trash' during an argument in a hospital room, was also reported to have had its guilty verdict reversed for the same reason in a Supreme Court judgment rendered on August 12, 2026.

There are limits to this reasoning, however. The Supreme Court made an exception for expressions based on discrimination or hatred regarding gender, race, ethnicity, disability, region of birth, sexual orientation, and the like (the above Decision 2023Do14750). In a case where a person repeatedly swore harshly at a police officer who had been dispatched to a restaurant with customers present, the Supreme Court held that it was an insult and reversed the acquittal (Supreme Court Decision 2016Do9674, October 13, 2016). If the swearing is repeated or the level of expression rises, the conclusion may change again.

Can It Be an Insult Without Swear Words – The Level of Expression

An insult means expressing an abstract judgment or contemptuous feeling that may lower a person's social reputation without stating facts (the above Decision 2016Do9674). So it is not the case that an insult requires a particular swear word. Even an expression without swear words, such as 'you are truly subhuman, your level shows,' can be assessed as an expression of contempt depending on the context.

Conversely, if the expression is merely rude and impolite enough to make the other person uncomfortable, or uses a minor abstract expression or swear word while expressing a negative or critical opinion or feeling, it does not, absent special circumstances, fall under the elements of insult (the above Decision 2025Do3012). The Supreme Court held that neither the remark 'how dare a young punk like you,' made in an apartment meeting room while stopping the other person from speaking down (the above Decision 2025Do3012), nor calling the other person an 'X-man' during a conflict among residents (Supreme Court Decision 2023Do8410, January 29, 2026), was an insult.

In short, whether swearing on KakaoTalk is a criminal insult is not decided by a single word. You need to consider together how open the conversation was, whether it could be known who was being referred to, the circumstances and context in which the remark was made, and whether it was a repeated expression or a momentary outburst. If you have been sued or are considering filing a complaint, it is advisable to preserve not only the message in question but the entire conversation before and after it, because circumstances and context are at the core of the judgment.

Cheongchul Law Firm directly handles criminal cases, including filing complaints for insult and defamation and defending suspects. If your situation is hard to judge on your own, please contact us through consultation booking.

This post is written for the purpose of providing legal information and does not constitute legal advice on any specific matter. Since conclusions may differ depending on the facts of each case, please be sure to consult a professional.

Related work cases that are good to see together

법무법인 청출 로고
법무법인 청출 로고
법무법인 청출

서울 강남구 테헤란로 403 리치타워 7층

Tel. 02-6959-9936

Fax. 02-6959-9967

cheongchul@cheongchul.com

개인정보처리방침

면책공고

© 2025. Cheongchul. All rights reserved

상담
신청
전화 상담 · 평일 09:00~18:0002-6959-9936
전화상담 상담 신청